data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cfbef/cfbefb44876c0d1ce1e6002f21966ddc2731d24d" alt="Picture"
In an earlier post, I suggested that job performance problems are typically the result of either low self-confidence (competence) or low self-esteem (motivation). My last post focused on looking for signs of cynicism as clues of low professional self-esteem, and then making improvements through career development. The result of improved self-esteem is an elevated motivation to succeed, and better overall job performance.
While motivation is expressed through self-esteem, competence is expressed through self-confidence, and is the result of appropriate knowledge, skills, and experience in a person’s work duties. Besides poor job performance, how can you tell if a team member is suffering from low self-confidence? Let’s face it—people are not going to tell you that they don’t know what they’re doing! We’re hard-wired to avoid feeling inadequate or foolish—and are silently fearful that we may lose our jobs if we are recognized as not being competent.
A good leader will recognize the signs of low professional self-confidence, diagnose which skills need developing, and help move the team to optimal performance and productivity.
A good leader will recognize the signs of low professional self-confidence, diagnose which skills need developing, and help move the team to optimal performance and productivity.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ef120/ef1204e7d340ab374a86ef97b1eef0a4e00cdc24" alt="Picture"
The classic sign of low self-confidence is masking. Masking is used to cover up a lack of competence. A metaphorical example of this would be the stereotypical high school athletic superstar who never learned to read well. How did he make it through school? By covering up for his reading skills in other ways.
What are some of the clues that a team member may be masking? Examples might include statements such as, “This is not a good example of how I usually do it.” “This training class is not real-world, so that is why I’m having trouble.” “I usually do much better than this, I don’t know what’s wrong with me today.” “I’m not good in these situations when you are with me, but I usually do much better by myself.” Of course, everyone has a bad day from time to time. However, continual rationalizing of poor performance, coupled with objective examples of low output, usually means a person is lacking certain skills.
Your job as a good leader, is to recognize these clues early on and to address any training needs immediately. What does it say about your leadership if your team does not get the training, feedback, and support they need and deserve to do their jobs well? The best place to start is with an honest conversation between you and your team about the skills in question. This can easily be accomplished when there is a “safe zone” of learning, coupled with mutual trust. Learning and taking risks are an important part of success in any field, and a culture that discourages honesty and punishes risk taking is not conducive to innovation and growth. A strong and confident leader will continually assess, teach, and reinforce skills on a routine basis. It all starts with you!
Your job as a good leader, is to recognize these clues early on and to address any training needs immediately. What does it say about your leadership if your team does not get the training, feedback, and support they need and deserve to do their jobs well? The best place to start is with an honest conversation between you and your team about the skills in question. This can easily be accomplished when there is a “safe zone” of learning, coupled with mutual trust. Learning and taking risks are an important part of success in any field, and a culture that discourages honesty and punishes risk taking is not conducive to innovation and growth. A strong and confident leader will continually assess, teach, and reinforce skills on a routine basis. It all starts with you!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/82b79/82b7931586b009efd5de800295ddc10e7935ebb0" alt="Picture"
By recognizing signs of cynicism and/or masking, and then taking strategic steps to begin improving motivation and competence, you will develop a high functioning team of people who are eager to succeed and capable of the highest level of performance in your organization. I hope these posts gave you some practical tips to address some of the all too common problems in the world of work.